
“Clayface” isn’t a great movie, but it does deliver on the promise of comic book to film adaptations. Specifically, that each of these pictures should be a different entity—they can exist in other genres besides “action” or “action-comedy” and they shouldn’t feel like it’s the same story being retold. Director James Watkins, working from a script by Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini, brings a horror retelling of one of Batman’s more interesting (and tragic) villains.. It doesn’t quite reach the heights it should, but there are enough engaging sequences that it still will entertain and intrigue audiences alike.
Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries) is a popular actor on the rise—coming from meager impoverished roots in Gotham, he’s now dominating the film scene with award nominations and successful projects. After one night partying in Gotham, he finds himself entangled with local criminal Markos Szabo (David Dencik), who has his goons attack, permanently disfiguring the young man. Soon Hagen finds himself without a career, without friends, without money, and completely hopeless. Until he learns about Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie) and her revolutionary nanotechnology that can treat permanent scars and other disabilities. Treatment seems like it’s going well, until Hagen pushes too far and soon discovers various side effects allowing him to change his appearance seemingly at will. How much of his humanity will be left as he uses these abilities to get revenge and change the course of his life?
When “Clayface” is at its best, it echoes either Sam Raimi’s “Darkman” in playful switcheroo fun or some genuinely creepy moments of body horror that feel akin to more recent titles like “The Substance” or “Daniel Isn’t Real.” (The mind reels at what Frank Henenlotter in his prime could have made of “Clayface” with the same budget and tools at his disposal) And those two gears are wonderfully engaging, truly making the audience to lean forward in their seats in glee or wince mightily at the self-lacerations and grotesque transformations Hagen undergoes. Unfortunately, those moments aren’t as plentiful as one would like but they are effective, nonetheless.
Rhys Harries is strong in his performance, and the ultimate arc of his character is powerful in its own right, but something is off in “Clayface” that deprives it of having more emotional resonance. Probably it’s the fault of the first act which moves very quickly to establish Hagen’s status before the attack, and then again speedily brushes through his downfall, before getting more regular paced once he starts his treatments with Corr. That rushed feeling doesn’t do enough to bond the audience emotionally with the character, nor does it set up any sort of foreshadowing to the darkness that exists within Hagen. So, while the body horror elements are harrowing and a sequence in a club with multiple changing appearances is delightful, the overall tragedy of the horror unfolding doesn’t hit as hard as it should. Make no mistake: it’s probably the better way to err in a movie like this, where viewers get the gist of the situation and the shorthand of who Hagen is and how much he’s lost; but it’s hard not to feel like that breezy summation is too efficient and not enough emphasis is placed on the humanity that will eventually disappear.
With that said, “Clayface” still has moments of brilliance in it, with the filmmakers taking cues from the comics as well as the “Batman: The Animated Series” episodes featuring the rogue but using them in edgier and more grounded ways. Yes, Watkins and company could’ve gone further with the horror and tragedy, but what we get is still nice in what could easily be dismissed as a comic book movie. Rhys Harries is a compelling lead doing what he can with the script, and the chemistry between him and Ackie fuels a lot of the scenes (and the downfall hits harder for it). The transformations between appearances is done exceptionally well by the special f/x team, comprised of both practical prosthetics/makeup work by Legacy Effects as well as digital work by a host of various companies, that helps sell the changes Hagen goes through as well as his abilities (and curse). Watkins also leads the effort by using tons of clever editing and camerawork by Jon Harris and Rob Hardy (respectively) to pull sort of sleight of hand in conjunction with the f/x team. It helps sell the validity of the threat Hagen poses as well as the potential calamity that awaits him as he transforms each time.
“Clayface” is a fun time that uses the language of horror overlayed on top of a pulpy revenge story to deliver a mostly engaging movie. The emotional element never hits as hard for as long as one wishes, instead of popping in some scenes here and there along the way, feeling rushed for half of the story. True, audiences would probably be bored if too much time was spent on either Hagen’s rise or the aftermath of his disfigurement, but a deft filmmaker would know how to better engage with viewers to make them truly invested in their lead and therefore get even more horrified and moved by the inevitable (and tragic) outcome. Watkins delivered a fine film on its own, but it’s hard not to see this movie about a shapeshifter and think of the ways it could’ve been made to resemble something better.
3.5 / 5 Stars
Directed by: James Watkins
Starring: Tom Rhys Harries, Naomi Ackie, Max Minghella, David Dencik, Joshua James, Eddie Marsan