#1 Record/Radio City
- Rock
- 2009
- Buy the CD
Reviewed by Jeff Giles
()
The music, of course, remains every bit as unimpeachable as it was when these albums were first released way back in 1972 and ’73; their 24 tracks represent one of the best opening one-two punches of any band in the rock era, and over 30 years later, it’s easy to trace their influence on countless power pop outfits that followed. At least in terms of sound, anyway – most acts go their entire careers without stringing together a series of songs as stellar as "Feel," "The Ballad of El Goodo," "In the Street," "Thirteen," and "Don’t Lie to Me," and Big Star did it in the first five tracks of their first album. Heard back to back, #1 Record and Radio City are 73 of the quickest minutes any pop music fan is likely to spend.
Here’s the thing, though: After languishing out of print for years, these albums were brought back in 1992, and they’ve remained available ever since; in fact, this latest edition – which tacks on the single mixes for "In the Street" and "O My Soul" as bonus tracks – exists alongside the ’92 two-fer, which is being sold for $5 more at Amazon. On one hand, it’s hard to begrudge Concord its decision to give the Big Star catalog any kind of attention, and George Horn’s remastering job does add quite a bit of brightness to both albums. On the other hand, though, the bonus material is a joke, and in light of Rhino’s plans to release a Big Star box later this year, it’s hard not to regard this reissue as something between crass and unnecessary.
Still, the important thing here is the music – and if you don’t own these albums, or you’ve ever had a problem with the softness in the mastering job of the ’92 reissue, or felt an urgent need to listen to a pair of Big Star single mixes, then this will be $9.99 well spent. If, on the other hand, you’re expecting a truly noticeable upgrade or expansion, or looking for something you haven’t heard before, you’re better off waiting for the box, due September 15.
You can follow us on Twitter and Facebook for content updates. Also, sign up for our email list for weekly updates and check us out on Google+ as well.